Old Bethpage, NY Real Estate — Homes For Sale in Old Bethpage, NY

    21 Properties Found

    Save Search
    Any Price: low to high Price: high to low Date: newest first Sq.Ft.: high to low $/Sq.Ft.: low to high $/Sq.Ft.: high to low Lot Size: high to low Monthly PMT: low to high Monthly PMT: high to low

    35 Photos Photos

    22 Farragut Road

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $1,198,000
    $4,675/mo
    • 4 beds
    • 4 baths
    • 1,916 sq ft
    • $625 / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of PATRICIA SALEGNA, DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE via OneKey MLS

    29 Photos Photos

    9 Lenmore Drive

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $799,888
    $3,121/mo
    • 4 beds
    • 3 baths
    • N/A sq ft
    • N/A / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of HOLLY GOTTLIEB, GOLDILOCKS REAL ESTATE via OneKey MLS

    35 Photos Photos

    273 Haypath Road

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $849,999
    $3,317/mo
    • 3 beds
    • 3 baths
    • N/A sq ft
    • N/A / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of MARLENE R STARR, DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE via OneKey MLS

    14 Photos Photos

    35 Prescott Place

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $810,000
    $3,161/mo
    • 4 beds
    • 2 baths
    • N/A sq ft
    • N/A / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of LESLYE J STERN, COMPASS GREATER NY LLC via OneKey MLS

    8 Photos Photos

    3 Maggio Lane

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $1,479,000
    $5,772/mo
    • 5 beds
    • 5 baths
    • 3,200 sq ft
    • $462 / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of NIRTEJ WADWA, PROPERTY PROFESSIONALS REALTY via OneKey MLS

    23 Photos Photos

    3 Belair Drive

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $1,449,000
    $5,655/mo
    • 5 beds
    • 5 baths
    • 3,510 sq ft
    • $413 / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of LINDA H FREEDMAN, DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE via OneKey MLS

    23 Photos Photos

    18 Melissa Lane

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $1,589,000
    $6,201/mo
    • 5 beds
    • 5 baths
    • 3,600 sq ft
    • $441 / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of PATRICIA SALEGNA, DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE via OneKey MLS

    26 Photos Photos

    33 Lark Court

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $559,888
    $2,185/mo
    • 3 beds
    • 1 baths
    • N/A sq ft
    • N/A / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of THOMAS MASTRANGELO, SIGNATURE PREMIER PROPERTIES via OneKey MLS

    36 Photos Photos

    15 Pasture Lane

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $1,088,888
    $4,249/mo
    • 4 beds
    • 4 baths
    • N/A sq ft
    • N/A / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of MARTINA SCHEBEN, COACH REAL ESTATE ASSOC INC via OneKey MLS

    15 Photos Photos

    7 Piper Place

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $549,000
    $2,142/mo
    • 3 beds
    • 2 baths
    • 1,072 sq ft
    • $512 / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of DAN ADAMS, MILLER REALTY GROUP via OneKey MLS

    23 Photos Photos

    8 Harrow Lane

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $1,598,000
    $6,236/mo
    • 5 beds
    • 5 baths
    • N/A sq ft
    • N/A / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of LINDA H FREEDMAN, DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE via OneKey MLS

    4 Photos Photos

    19 Lark Avenue

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $1,299,000
    $5,069/mo
    • 4 beds
    • 3 baths
    • N/A sq ft
    • N/A / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of KOORESH SHOOSHTARY, SIGNATURE PREMIER PROPERTIES via OneKey MLS

    1 Photos Photos

    68 Schoolhouse Road

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $499,990
    $1,951/mo
    • 3 beds
    • 2 baths
    • N/A sq ft
    • N/A / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of IDA L VERGARA, DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY via OneKey MLS

    17 Photos Photos

    68A Schoolhouse Road

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $1,599,000
    $6,240/mo
    • 5 beds
    • 5 baths
    • 3,600 sq ft
    • $444 / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of PATRICIA SALEGNA, DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE via OneKey MLS

    21 Photos Photos

    36 Beatrice Lane

    Old Bethpage, NY 11804
    $1,300,000
    $5,073/mo
    • 4 beds
    • 3 baths
    • 2,254 sq ft
    • $577 / sq ft
    • Single Family Residence
    Listing Provided Courtesy of NICHOLAS OLIVER, HAUSEIT LLC via OneKey MLS
    Activating this element will cause content on the page to be updated. 1 2

    Real Estate Market Trends in Old Bethpage, NY

    Coldwell Banker estimates the median home price in Old Bethpage is $1,295,000. Right now, there are 21 homes listed for sale in Old Bethpage, including 0 condos and 0 foreclosures. You can research home values, browse Old Bethpage's hottest homes, and see what Coldwell Banker's agents have to say about the local area. Check out our page on Old Bethpage market trends to start exploring!

    Real Estate Resources for Long Island, NY

    Nearby Postal Codes

    Nearby Cities

    If you're looking to buy a home in Old Bethpage, NY, you've come to the right place. Coldwell Banker keeps you up to date with the latest Old Bethpage MLS listing - including new homes for sale, townhomes for sale, condos for sale, foreclosed homes for sale, and land for sale. With Coldwell Banker's mobile app and website, you can customize your Old Bethpage home search to help find the right place for you, from the location you love to the number of bedrooms and bathrooms. You can get even more specific with keyword search. Want to picture your life in Old Bethpage? Try checking out our interactive maps, photos, and school information. And when you're ready to talk to a real estate agent, Coldwell Banker has ratings and reviews written by real estate clients nationwide to help you find a great agent.
    Loading....