Mary Carlisle

    Mary Carlisle

    Satisfaction Rating An agent's star rating is the average of all the ratings of their service.
    I have lived in Chestertown since 2002. I love our small town and I especially enjoy showing people the town and all it has to offer.
    I am an experienced full-time Realtor representing Sellers and Buyers in Kent and Queen Annes Counties I have built my business in a difficult market by providing exceptional service to my Clients who then refer others to me.
    I have been selling real estate on the Eastern Shore of MD since 2005. I love working with Buyers and showing them homes in this beautiful area. If you are considering a purchase please contact me. I will assist you with my knowledge of the local market and my understanding of what it takes to make a transaction go smoothly. It really pays to work with someone local because our market is much different from other areas. My areas of expertise are Kent and Queen Annes counties.

    My Client Reviews

    (22 reviews)
    Overall star rating: 5.0
    Past 3 months: N/A

    Ratings Breakdown

    Star Rating Percentage of reviews with this rating Number of reviews with this rating
    5 stars
    100% of Mary’s ratings: 5 stars
    4 stars
    0% of Mary’s ratings: 4 stars
    3 stars
    0% of Mary’s ratings: 3 stars
    2 stars
    0% of Mary’s ratings: 2 stars
    1 stars
    0% of Mary’s ratings: 1 star

    Showing All Reviews (22)

    Show only: 5 stars 4 stars 3 stars 2 stars 1 star show all
    Sherwin gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Mary is the consummate professional. She knows.her stuff, but she is always calm and is willing and ready to deal with any problem that arises. Yet without fail pleasant and positive
    Kathryn gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Mary was recommended to me by some friends. I live on the opposite side of the country so everything has been done via Face Time, video clips etc. to show me places I was interested in. Mary was always reachable, quick to answer questions, and to visit properties I was interested in. Always congenial. Really exceeded my expectations.
    Jenny gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Mary has done a phenomenal job helping me navigate the buying and selling process. She has great connections to local contractors who were able to give professional opinions on issues with the 1920 house I bought. She helped me negotiate a good deal on buying my house, and to sell my house within three days for over asking price. She quickly answered any questions or concerns I had and helped the whole process go smoothly.
    Lance gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    My wife and I have known Mary for ten years whether enacting a real estate solution or running into her at the Saturday farmers market in Chestertown, MD. Mary is a delight, straightforward and resourceful. With regard to her professional acumen Mary is intrinsically observant, receptive, knowledgeable and wholly immersed in every facet of real estate marketing. She brings her network of contacts to your benefit which leads me to believe she is highly respected among her peers. I highly recommend her. Place your trust in her. Tell her what you wish to accomplish, she'll get you there!
    Linda gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    I met Mary when I asked to view one of her exclusive listings in Chestertown. I felt comfortable with Mary and proceeded to work with her as a buyer's agent. She was exceptionally "on the spot" for whatever place I wanted to view and provided all follow up information needed. I felt strongly I could rely on Mary's advice when negotiating a final offer.
    Tobin gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Mary really listened to us when we told her what we were looking for in a house and kept us on track for what we wanted even when we started to look at properties on a whim that would not have met our desires. She has a very subtle way of guiding her clients without being pushy. She had our best interests in mind and was not out to just sell another house. In the end she found us the perfect house that matched all of our wish list desires.
    Kathleen gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Mary went the extra mile to help me with so many of the adjacent activities tied to moving. The time between selling and settling was short, and she helped me quickly look at rentals and followed up with contractors to complete last minute items. Mary also worked with the title company to insure everything would go well because I had moved out of state. During the sales process she was optimistic, responsive and diligent on following up with questions or requests.
    John gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    5 Stars for Mary. I'd give 10 if it were an option. Working with Mary was a delight. From our first meeting with her she was engaged and listened to us as we searched for a new home. The listings she sent were relevant and met our criteria. When we found our new home she was on top of every detail and worked with us until the deal was done. Mary is a wonderful and caring person and will certainly use her again when the time comes.
    Steve gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    During our time searching for a new home, Mary went the extra mile to ensure our time was optimized by searching for potential options, setting time for showings and providing input as to the area in which we were looking. She maintained communications with use by phone and E-mail whenever a new opportunity came available and was ALWAYS available to answer any questions we had. Whenever we needed someone to follow up on activities necessary after we found our home, but would not be able to due ourselves, she was there to help without question. GREAT JOB!!!
    Adalbert gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Mary was always available and super responsive. She was always on top of everything and followed up when needed. Very professional, with lots of local knowledge. Stayed calm when Covid interfered and gave good advise.
    Amy gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    I rated Mary with five stars because she was very professional, very kind , willing to help with anything ( I was selling my father's house after he passed away and we lived 2 hours away so it was extremely helpful to have someone willing to do things so I did not have to come down). If I texted a question or a concern she always got back to me that day. I felt the sale of my father's house was in the right hands.
    Bernie gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Mary is excellent. Her local knowledge and experience helped us in many ways, including providing resources for us and using all resources available to her throughout the process. We could always count on Mary to promptly respond to our questions and to immediately share information she received. Her calmness and excellent listening skills assured us that she always had our best interest in mind.
    Sara Ann gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    To me, Mary is the ideal realtor. She's good at figuring out what you want and what you should have and gently guides you toward making the decisions that are right for you. I am completely satisfied with way she handled the transaction from beginning to end. She was always there for me when I felt bogged down by the process and I had complete confidence in the advice she gave me. I highly recommend her.
    Jacob gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Mary has been working with us for several months to help us find a home that was right for us. This was our first house purchase and she worked with us through every step of the process. She was extremely knowledgeable when it came to putting together the offers, what to expect from FHA appraisals and what they would be looking at on the homes, and the warning signs that some of the homes we had looked at were. When we wanted additional information on a house such as old documentation on water/septic changes, she would dig and be able to get it for us. She was extremely responsive and would get back to me within a day of asking a question. Overall, we are extremely happy with her and would recommend her to anyone.
    Response from Mary
    Thank you Jacob! I really enjoyed working with you and Heather!
    Susan L. gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    I have worked with Mary on several property sales and several property purchases. Each time I purchased a new home, Mary kept my best interests at heart and kept me abreast of properties that met my desires.
    Robert gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Mary was a professional in every way. She brought in qualified buyers. Good communication and feedback. We were very pleased with her finding a new owner that would fit this residence and commercial property.
    Robyn gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Mary Carlisle was our realtor for our move to Chestertown. She was, hands down, the best realtor I have ever worked with!!! She went over and beyond to help us get the house we liked. She contacted the HOA to see if they would approve the improvements we wanted to make and then recommended very good local service companies (electricians, painters, plumbers, etc) to help us once we moved in. She is very helpful, organized, detail oriented and made this a stress free experience!!!
    Susan gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Not only was Mary incredibly professional to work with, she suggested we look at a home that wasn't on our list. Guess which home we purchased! Mary was organized, knowledgable, and a joy to work with.
    Drex gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Mary was a delight to work with throughout our entire purchase process,with a (by intention) five month escrow and bi-coastal distance. Mary was utterly professional, relaxed and down to earth, patient at all times....fielded questions, sourced professional input, returned all calls promptly, checked in regularly and coordinated a very complicated deal with the greatest of ease. I highly recommend working with her! She will become a friend in our new found community.
    Mary Alice gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    I moved to Chestertown for a new job at Washington College not knowing anyone in town. Mary quickly became my trusted source of all things local. She guided me through challenging negotiations to buy a home that I am delighted to call my own. Just as Mary was recommended to me by a new colleague I am happy to recommend her to others.
    George gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Mary is a superb realtor. She is extremely knowledgeable about real estate matters. In addition, she got to know us in such a way as to anticipate our needs and find exactly the property we were searching for to make it our home. The entire process could not have been smoother. We give Mary the highest recommendation for service, cordiality and detail.
    Heidi gave Mary 5 stars out of 5
    Mary is a great realtor who made a complicated out of state sale work for us. I've never met her just handled everything via phone, email or text. Her day to day attention to detail was wonderful as I was not local. Sale documents handled completely electronically and quick. Wonderful Christmas present to have finally settled on our sale. Highly recommend!

    My Credentials and Memberships

    • Bay Area Association Of Realtors
    • National Association of Realtors
    • Maryland Association of Realtors
    • 2012 Coldwell Banker International Sterling Society
    • 2013 Coldwell Banker International Sterling Society
    • 2014 Coldwell Banker International Diamond Society
    • 2016 Coldwell Banker International Diamond Society
    • 2017 Coldwell Banker International Diamond Society
    • 2020 Coldwell Banker International Diamond Society

    Local Insights

    My Video

    Follow Me

    Share My Page

    Go Mobile

    Want to take your search on the go and find nearby homes? Download my free mobile app.

    Goto Apple app store to download iOS app Goto Google play store to download the app